Why is my cash different to my profit?
You have been running your business by looking at how much is in the bank account, but when your accountant prepares your year end accounts the profit figure doesn’t feel right because it is different from the cash figure that you had in your head. Does this sound like you?
It is a common enough scenario. Often the next stage in this scenario is that self doubt kicks in, you start asking yourself if all of the decisions you took during the year based on the bank account were wrong, but there is a solution and it involves working with you bookkeeper or accountant throughout the year to look at reports regularly.
But first, let’s take a look at some of the reasons why profit and cash can be different. We’ll use a 31 December 2021 year end for our example.
1. Bills payable
Any invoices received from your suppliers and recorded in your accounts will show as a cost in 2021 if the bill is dated on or before 31 December 2021. It doesn’t matter when you pay the bill. If you pay the bill in January 2022, February 2022 or later, it will still show as a cost in 2021 because of the date of the supplier’s invoice.
This means it will reduce your profit but not your cash.
2. Debtors receivable
This is similar to bills payable. Let’s say that you send out invoices to your clients in December 2021 but they don’t pay you until January 2022. This will be income in your accounts in 2021 because that’s the date on the invoice. It doesn’t matter that you don’t have the cash yet.
This means that it will increase your profit but not your cash.
3. Income in advance
You might also hear this called deferred income.
Let’s imagine that your business runs courses, you have a new course starting in January 2022 and people have been booking and paying in November and December 2021 to get their place on the course. This will be money in your bank account. But the income doesn’t belong to 2021. You will earn that income in 2022 when you run the course.
The principle at play here is all about trying to match income to the right time period it relates to.
This can mean that profit will decrease but not your cash.
4. Accrued income
This is similar to income in advance, but it is the other way around.
If you invoice your clients in arrears then you may have done work in 2021 but have not invoiced your client until January 2022. If that is that case then you and your accountant may accrue for the income in 2021, even though you haven’t invoiced for it or been paid for it yet.
It’s the principle of trying to match income to the time period is relates to again.
This scenario is common when grants are promised but not yet received, our not for profit clients see this happening. They may receive a grant offer pre year end but not receive the cash until 2022. Income recognition for charities follows particular rules but in many cases it would be right to include the income in 2021 even though they don’t get the cash until 2022.
This can mean that profit will increase but not your cash.
5. Prepayments
We’re still on the matching principle here. Typical examples will be things like insurance or subscriptions which you pay for in advance. If you pay for your company’s annual insurance in advance in July 2021 and it covers July 2021 – June 2022 then only 6 months worth of that cost really belong to 2021. The other 6 months are a prepayment towards 2022.
So you have paid the full bill and your cash has gone down, but it’s not all a cost this year.
This adjustment will increase your profit but not your cash.
6. Accruals
Accruals are the opposite of prepayments.
Imagine that you ran an event in December 2021. You will have costs of venue hire, catering and entertainment and others. These costs clearly belong in 2021, you received the benefit of these services in 2021. But if your suppliers don’t invoice you until January 2022 then probably you won’t pay for the services until February 2022.
A year end adjustment would be to accrue for the cost of these services so that the cost moves into December 2021 even though the supplier bills are received in January 2022 and you pay in February 2022.
This adjustment will decrease your profit but not your cash.
7. Tax
The final example here is tax.
Assuming you are running a profitable VAT registered business then you will be paying VAT on your purchases which you can reclaim and you will be charging VAT when you invoice your customers which you have to pay over to HMRC. So some of the money sitting in your bank account really belongs to HMRC.
Assuming that your business is profitable then you will be paying corporation tax. Tax is another cost. The year end accounts will include tax, but as at 31 December 2021 you won’t have paid this tax yet, so the money should still be in your bank account.
This means your profit after tax will reduce by the value of the tax charge for the year, but by 31 December your cash won’t have reduced.
Sometimes people get a nasty surprise here when they realize that they haven’t got enough cash in their account to pay the corporation tax bill. If this is you then a practical solution in future can be to open a separate bank account and to move money into it at regular intervals during the year. It makes sense to do this monthly or quarterly in line with the frequency at which you review your reports. Then by the time you get to your year end you should have the cash safely put away ready to pay your corporation tax bill.
This is by no means the final possible thing which could cause differences between cash and profit, there are others, but these are some of the most common and should give you a good flavour.
So what’s the solution?
This is why it is important to work closely with your bookkeeper/ accountant during the year and not just have an accountant who swoops in once a year to prepare the accounts. Working with a good professional should give you confidence about understanding the numbers and making decisions based on them all the way through the year. If you work with a good bookkeeper/ accountant who is giving you good reports each month or quarter, then there shouldn’t be too many surprises by the time you get to the year end.
We prepare the year end accounts and tax for some of our clients and we have chosen to provide this service primarily to clients we already have a relationship with because we do their bookkeeping and payroll. It means that we know them better and can provide a better quality holistic service.
We use Xero for bookkeeping and some reporting, and have used Spotlight for more sophisticated reporting and forecasting.
If you want to know more then get in touch:
0330 1330 774